The Presumption Of Abuse And Qualification For Chapter 7 Discharge

Significant Changes to the Bankruptcy Code underincome" comprised of all sources of income for the
the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumerhousehold.  The debtor's current monthly income is
Protection Act of 2005 (BAPCPA):  The Presumptionthen offset by a set of deductions specified by the
of Abuse and Qualification for Chapter 7 DischargeInternal Revenue Service.  In general, the allowable
The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumerdeductions applicable in the means test include:
Protection Act of 2005 (BAPCPA) represented the1. Certain specified living expenses,
most sweeping change to the Bankruptcy Code since2. Contributions to care of nondependent family
the modern bankruptcy code was enacted in 1978. members,
It was roundly criticized and opposed by the bench3. Expenses of administering a Chapter 13 repayment
and bar, consumer advocates, and legalplan,
commentators, but a potent lobby by creditors, led4. Educational expenses up to $1,500 annually per
by credit card banks were able to convince thechild,
Congress to enact the significant amendments which5. Home energy costs,
were viewed as largely business friendly changes to6. A percentage of certain secured debt,
the law.7. Expenses "reasonably necessary health insurance,
Perhaps the most significant change to thedisability insurance, and health savings account
bankruptcy code under BAPCPA was theexpenses,"
"Presumption of Abuse."  Under the pre-BAPCPA8. Expenses for protection from family violence,
bankruptcy code, debtors could file for bankruptcy9. A percentage of all priority debt, and
under Chapter 7 liquidation or total discharge,10.  Contributions to tax-exempt charities.
regardless of their income level.  Under the BAPCPAAfter the debtor's income and expenses are
amendments, debtors had to prove that theysummed, the court or trustee considers whether a
qualified for Chapter 7 bankruptcy.  BAPCPA creates"presumption of abuse" exists.  Such a presumption
a method to calculate a debtor's income, andexists if the debtor has at least $166.67 in current
compares this figure to the median income of themonthly income after the allowed deductions, the
debtor's state.  If the debtor's household incomedebtor has at least $100 of such income and this sum
falls below the median income for the state, then thewould be enough to pay general unsecured creditors
debtor automatically qualifies to file for Chapter 7more than 25% over five years (i.e., they could
bankruptcy.successfully enter into a Chapter 13 repayment
If the debtor's income is above the median incomeplan).  Absent special circumstances, if the debtor
amount of the debtor's state, the debtor is subject"fails" the means test, he or she cannot seek
to a "means test."  The means test works roughlyChapter 7 liquidation or total discharge.  Rather, he
like this:or she must petition for a repayment plan under
The debtor first calculates the "current monthlyChapter 13.